A total of 49 people were present to watch. When I got my gun back, we still didnt have enough money, so we went to do another robbery, where I wound up shooting a fellow named Dennis Tapp, who survived, thank God.. [4] In 1967, Evelyn abandoned Robert, then 14, in Sacramento and left him to fend for himself. Robert Alton Harris | Found a Grave His lack of comprehension that deaths are different must come from a lack of exposure to actual death. We know what justice is, unless we are philosophers or lawyers. He was officially pronounced dead at 6:21 a.m. When Harris turned 19, authorities could no longer hold him. [2] During his time at the juvenile detention centre, Harris was repeatedly raped. Steps taken to delay or annul his execution illustrate some of the arguments against the death penalty. [2][6] He spent the next three years in the Florida juvenile detention system, but when he turned 19, the system could no longer keep him, and he was sent to Chula Vista, California. Robert Harris spent the next four years as a ward of federal reformatories. He might as well have been a brute force of nature, like a tornado. A hearing is scheduled before U.S. District Judge Howard B. Turrentine at 9 a.m. today. San Diego murders Sometime in May or June 1978, Robert, then aged 25, asked his brother Daniel, 18, for help in planning a bank robbery. The innocent release in gratitude for their release. A probation officers report noted that his parents whereabouts were unknown. In the last few years I have taken up a discipline of forgiveness, which means I have decided against vengeance as a guide. Killing a few murderers will not make a bit of difference in lowering our crime rates. Do not underestimate the intensity of the egos drive for vengeance on the past. [15] On April 18, U.S. District Judge Marilyn Hall Patel issued a temporary restraining order barring Harris' execution while she considered his lawsuit challenging the gas chamber's constitutionality. After crossing the chasm that forever separated them from the social contract, they found some kind of freedom outside the realm of conscience, outside the realm of society. On March 6, 1979, Robert Harris was convicted in the San Diego County Superior Court of two counts of murder in the first degree with special circumstances as well as two counts of kidnapping, and was sentenced to death. There still are no pictures of tall, blue-eyed Michael Baker on the walls of the Mankins's home. SAN FRANCISCO (AP) _ To prosecutors and the families of his victims, Robert Alton Harris is a vicious murderer who laughed about killing two teen-agers and told one to ''quit crying and die like a man.'' Magris was arrested several hours later and charged with murder, kidnapping, robbery, and attempted murder. A $300-million (minimum) gondola to Dodger Stadium? "I haven't had a postcard even acknowledging, 'Yes, Mrs. Mankins, we're taking your feelings into consideration.' Margarito Angeles Vargas, 46, is accused of hitting 19-month-old Annaleeh Rodarte the evening of Sept. 24, 2022 on Redwood Street near 40th Street, Robin McPherson, now 68, was slated to appear for a March 2001 sentencing hearing following his convictions for tax evasion and conspiracy, but instead fled the country, according to the Department of Justice, No charges were ever filed by South Dakota authorities against T. Denny Sanford, who has donated nearly $1 billion to San Diego institutions. Id see guys lives change over an exchange of bad words, Magris remembers. Millers article did not have the effect on me that he intended. According to court testimony by Daniel Harris, this happened: Robert Harris promised not to harm the boys, then shot Mayeski in the head and back, killing him. It helps us to understand what forgiveness really is: not the self-sacrificing acceptance of wrongs that have been done to us, but rather the willingness to recover a long-abandoned world of peace by questioning both the sanity and reality of the world we have built on vengeance. We continue to hype and glorify violence: as entertainment; as proof of our strength as individuals, as tribes, and as a nation; and finally, as the best or final answer to violence itself. [5] Mayeski and Baker were best friends who had planned to spend the day fishing to celebrate Mayeski's newly acquired driver's license. If it costs fifty thousand dollars a year to secure a prisoner, thats one million dollars over twenty years. Harris was paroled in January 1978. You do somebody wrong in prison and theyre gonna do you the ultimate wrong. In such an environment, Magriss turnabout must necessarily be seen as an exception to the rule, if not an outright miracle. Today Harris became the 502nd person to be put to death by the state of California. His mother died in 1981 of cancer. People like Miller can teach and write only so long as the state has the power to crush thugs. . Harris' Final Appeals Stress Brother's Role - Los Angeles Times "The process has been too long and too cumbersome.". The life history of Robert Alton Harris, as reported by Times writer Dan Morain, reads like a surreally brutal recipe for the making of a callous murderer. Kolender, who was appointed director of the California Youth Authority last year, said he hoped Harris death would bring peace to the families of his victims. In the hard wiring that is human nature, maybe all those contradictory messages that alternately tell us to hit back, run, or stand tall in the face of violence can give us a clue that there is no simple solution. Magris emphatically believes so, arguing that society could be spending money and energy in more positive approaches to rehabilitation, which in the long run would be far more economical. When murderers torture and slay the vulnerable bodies of their victims, we are reminded of our own tenuous physicality, and we react with a fearful rage. David Magris is the son of an Italian father and Puerto Rican mother who were unmarried at the time of his birth in 1948 in Vallejo, California. Such questioning will not immediately yield a deathless world of spirit, for we have gone too deep into our illusions for that. He mouthed the words, looking me square in the eye: `Im sorry. I nodded my head at him.. In that sense, political activism in the name of forgiveness can be seen as an important part of a transformational spiritual discipline. WebThe defendant, Robert Alton Harris, and his brother, co-defendant Daniel Marcus Harris, abducted two teenage boys. Fear will run rampant in your mind if you allow it, and when it does, it becomes bigger than life. And I dont want to forgive robbers. In 1968, after his brother tried to stop him from sniffing glue, Robert ran off, stole a car, and was arrested in Florida. If we want to see how angry we are about this unhappy circumstance, we need only look at our treatment of murderers. Janice Gay demonstrated outside San Quentin against the execution of Robert Alton Harris in 1992. He knew vaguely that his biological father was a bad person--his mother had told him so. He would spend the rest of his days behind bars, they predicted. LAST SECOND DELAY OF EXECUTION MADE IT `TORTURE,` To stop the death penalty once and for all, we must be willing to question the reality of this world of death. [7] Harris was paroled in January 1978. Taught from the womb onward that the world runs on senseless violence, Harris behaved with a chronic viciousness that clearly suggested he was incapable of making sensible choices. Linda Herring, now 26 and married, was convinced that she would be next to die, Sharron Mankins said. He said; "You can be a king or a street sweeper but everybody dances with the Grim Reaper". And then you have to decide to become stronger than your fear. "[10][11] Wilson then left without waiting for reporters' questions. Now let me see if I got this straight: some lady hears voices telling her that the spiritual world is real and the material world is an illusion. His younger brother, Daniel, 18, was willing to help. Lisa ByBee, stepsister of victim Michael Baker, hugs friend Valerie Giefer after learning of the last stay of execution of Robert Alton Harris from Ed Mayeski, brother of John Mayeski. Instead we should give the victims and their families the option of either killing their offenders swiftly and cheaply or enslaving them to community service. Perhaps we were simply too cowardly to take up a gun or a knife. His death cant bring those boys back, he said. From the archives: Time runs out for killer of 2 youths here Merely crushing them is no answer either; a state that has only force is just as precarious as one that lacks the will to use it. He would beat him with a bamboo cane and taunt him with a loaded gun, telling him to run. But our actions must be open to some evaluation in the here and now. The investigation revealed that at 10:30 a.m. on July 5, 1978, the defendant and co And then we take two steps back.". After a fruitless search, they drove to a fast-food restaurant for lunch. [International Phenomenological Society, Philosophy and Phenomenological Research, Wiley]: 12942. After Robert shot Vasquez had planned to provide a prison chaplain for Harris, but opposed allowing the prisoners second cousin into the prison on the night of the execution, saying that it might lead to a desperate act to free Harris or interfere with the execution. What does this metaphysical perspective have to do with the politics of capital punishment and our vengeful incarceration of criminals? None of this was true, Magris knows today, but he asserts that the idea that he came from criminal stock was a powerful influence on him. Baker said he finds it "totally ridiculous that it would take 14 years to punish someone like Harris. Miller concluded in A Brutal Sadness that to demonstrate or legislate with full force against the death penalty is to acknowledge that we are actually campaigning to change human nature. I have scarcely read a more arrogant sentence in print. Robert Alton Harris I never thought in my life that this would come over me. I think lethal injection is much cleaner, more surgical, quicker, Leary said. Rev. The previous essays in this series are Back to the Real World [Issue 153], Climbing the Stone Face of Fear [Issue 164], and Homeless [Issue 166]. But it doesnt work so nicely. To have forgiven him would have been to say, We will no longer teach vengeance to you or your victims. 21 April 1992 Robert Alton Harris . [5] He was convicted of voluntary manslaughter and imprisoned in San Luis Obispo;[2] during his imprisonment Harris' wife filed for divorce. In 1978, Robert Alton Harris and his brother, Daniel Marcus Harris, went to a fast food restaurant and abducted two teenage boys. Robert Alton Harris | Opinion 1989 - Murderpedia Magris recalls, I had a gun, and I gave it to one of the other three guys to do a service station. Capital punishment allows us the choice of spending that one million on food and books and education for a lot of desperate, hungry five-year-olds in this world. A memorial, an act of rebellion, a reminder of survival. The old man clubbed his son in the head with a wrench. Yet what is poignantly missing and systematically suppressed in our society is the voice of our conscience when we face the choice of killing or not killing. In the safety of Juvenile Hall, she began revealing the sexual things her father would do to the girls. A full seven minutes passed -- pierced by intermittent moans, gasps and convulsions -- before it seemed that Robert Harris mind and his body had fully passed into unconsciousness, Hearn said. They were having slap fights and were still fighting at 9 p.m. Millers account of David Magris, the reformed felon, gave me profound satisfaction. Where is the criminals accountability in all of this? In an order signed by Chief Justice Malcolm M. Lucas, the court said it had carefully read and considered legal arguments from both sides. We love getting letters to the editor for our Correspondence section. Needing a car, the Harris brothers spotted Baker and Mayeski and kidnapped them, planning to use the teenagers car for their robbery. Apparently it required being sent to the gas chamber for him to experience sincere remorse for his crime. The Course asserts that the world we see veils the answer: You do not understand how what you see arose to meet your sight. Nor does not executing a convicted murderer. In denying mercy, Wilson said he sympathized with Harris for having been the victim of alcoholic and abusive parents but said he could not excuse or forgive the choice made by Robert Harris the man.. "We've sent letters to Governor Wilson, and I haven't had a call back," she said. But in a time when youngsters are murdering each other over athletic shoes, we can presume that many peoples love of life is so weak that the theory of deterrence hardly applies to them. The Course is a one-year, self-study curriculum that guides its students toward an instinctive, utilitarian spirituality by restoring their contact with what it calls the Internal Teacher. Published in 1976, the Course was written down over a period of seven years by Columbia University research psychologist Helen Schucman, who claimed to hear a soundless voice giving her a compelling inner dictation. Schucman, who died in 1981, never claimed authorship of the Course. People who idealistically face violence with nonviolence have often been mowed down. To those who favor capital punishment, his case came to symbolize their frustrations with a legal system that allows lengthy appeals by a killer condemned to die. [15][16], On April 20, the U.S. Supreme Court vacated a separate stay of execution the Ninth Circuit had issued on Harris' habeas corpus petition. If we can't execute Harris, we won't be able to execute anyone.". He claimed that hed only watched others do it. At Miramar Lake, the Harris brothers ordered the boys to kneel, whereupon the boys began to pray. He was Michael's father and at the time had been divorced from Sharron Mankins for almost 12 years. He also serves as a board member of Centerforce, an organization that manages hospitality houses at state prisons, where the visiting families of inmates are greeted and assisted with child care. We discuss his true crime history, his execution , and we eat his last meal. We resign ourselves to the random destruction wrought by tornadoes because we cant change nature. We do not have the political will to cease serving as the number-one arms merchant to the world. To change human nature religions and belief systems and psychology never tire of this rhetoric. Robert was 39 years old. Id say you have a right as a victim or loved one of a victim to get resolution, he says. He said he had never before seen the extraordinary legal action taken by the U.S. Supreme Court in Harris case. God and nature get off the hook for apparently committing murders because we have no way of punishing either of them. The adult Robert Alton Harris lost his right to live. . [6][8], The San Diego County District Attorney's Office filed felony charges of auto theft, kidnapping, murder and burglary against Robert Harris, while the U.S. Attorney's Office filed bank robbery charges against him. The real world is the state of mind in which the only purpose of the world is seen to be forgiveness. Sharron, a bookkeeper, and Sam, a teacher, work for the San Diego City School District. What would his wife be like?' A woman in the area where the families of Harris victims were sitting cried out: Oh God!. In sum, God and nature get off the hook for apparently committing murders because we have no way of punishing either of them. If we presume that God brings all natural deaths to us, why not exact a death penalty from our Creator? The equation is simple and so blatantly clear in human history and in the daily news that one has to wonder why our modern society has not yet grasped it. But when they do choose abortion, with a conscience full of prayer, the very act of their spiritual struggle is a lifting up of the human spirit for all of humanity. Think of Anwar Sadat. "After Tammy's death, I felt afraid I'd lose Linda too," Sharron said of her sole surviving child by Baker. Seconds before the cyanide gas filled the chamber, Harris had looked squarely into the eyes of Steve Baker, the father of one of the two San Diego teen-age boys Harris murdered. He didnt joke, he didnt laugh, he didnt roll his eyes, as he did frequently during the earlier failed attempt to kill him. These responses embody the spiritual values presumably endorsed by a nation with a Christian majority, yet we do not endorse them. For his last meal, he requested and was given a 21-piece bucket of Kentucky Fried Chicken, two large Domino's pizzas, a bag of jelly beans, a six-pack of Pepsi, and a pack of Camel cigarettes. WebRobert Alton HARRIS, and his brother, Daniel Marcus Harris, abducted two teenage boys from a fast food restaurant, forcing them to drive to an isolated area. Robert stole a car and was arrested in Florida, winding up as a ward of federal reformatories for the next four years. Five years after Michael's murder, tragedy struck the family again when Tammy Baker, Steve and Sharron's daughter, was thrown from the back of a motorcycle and killed the night before her 18th birthday. According to the Los Angeles Times, Clark had had a vivid dream a few weeks before the execution, in which Harriss death unleashed a cloud of black gremlins that shrieked and flew in circles around his head before descending, tornado like, into hell. Robert Alton Harris San Quentin, California On July 5, 1978, Robert and his brother Daniel found John Mayeski and Michael Baker, both 16, eating hamburgers in Mayeski's car celebrating his new driver's license. The only way to have peace is to teach peace. Chikatilo, the Russian criminal who is estimated to have tortured, killed, and eaten more than fifty people, loved to mutilate their genitals. It created a very positive effect on day-to-day living in a place where racial and territorial tensions were still prevalent.. Why? Robert Harris did not stop with his fists. In 1975 he was imprisoned for manslaughter and paroled in January 1978. And then I did.. Arizona, which conducted its first execution in 30 years on April 7, is considering a switch to lethal injection. [15] Seconds before execution, Ninth Circuit Judge Harry Pregerson stayed the execution for the fourth time, explaining that Harris should be allowed to begin a new lawsuit in state court. One of the officers who apprehended the Harris brothers was Steven Baker, father of victim Michael Baker, who at the time was unaware that his son had been killed, let alone by one of the men he was arresting. He said it was too soon to know whether witnessing Harris death closed a horrible chapter in his life. I saw a lot of changes in other prisoners ability to forgive, he says. Forgiveness is often mistaken for the passive acceptance of wrongdoing and the denial of anger. Youve been hurt or no longer have someone you loved, so you feel robbed, cheated, and abandoned, and that makes you angry and afraid. Societal adulthood is even tougher than Becker thinks. He slapped my face several times, banged my head against a tree, and laughed, Go ahead, pussy. My mother said I should be understanding because his father used to tie him up and punch the daylights out of him and that was the only kind of life he knew. In recent years, we have decided, by at least a three-fourths majority according to most polls, that we do want capital punishment administered in due course to convicted murderers. [15] That night, the U.S. Supreme Court issued a per curiam decision vacating the Ninth Circuit's stays and allowing the execution to proceed, by a vote of 72. Robert Davis was Robert Alton Harris Jr. [13], In 1990, federal appeals court judge John T. Noonan Jr. issued a stay of execution, as Harris argued that childhood brain damage interfered with his judgment during his crimes. Robert Alton Harris (1953-1992) - Find a Grave Memorial 1 Along with many other challenges to the conviction and sentence, Or is the most humane action for them and for the citizens who pay for their trials, attorneys, medical care, food, and clothes to kill them as quickly as possible after their conviction and cease this argument that a Chikatilo is somehow like us? Violence might come to us at random, as Harris came to young Baker and Mayeski, and we would be unprepared to protect ourselves or avenge the deaths of the innocent. Even if we conclude that he knew better and was capable of not making such a horrendous decision, the fact remains that he did this insane thing for no discernible reason other than the compulsion of his own horrific past. At 4:01 a.m., guards entered the chamber and unstrapped Harris from the chair. I couldnt forgive him. "It was a terrible loss. One of the arresting officers, Steve Baker, was the father of one of the murdered boys, but did not realize the victim was his son until later. The voice of the Course identifies itself as the living consciousness of Jesus Christ and offers a number of corrections to modern Christian beliefs. As the old saying goes, life itself is a fatal disease. Movies. On July 2, Daniel stole Howard I. Friedman criticized Wilson for ignoring scientific evidence that Harris suffers from fetal alcohol syndrome. When we think about it, most of us know that vengeance isnt justice, because justice is what we want for ourselves and vengeance is what we wish on people we think dont deserve justice: criminals, homosexuals, the homeless, people of other races, people who have AIDS. Through the windows of the soundproof chamber, many of the forty-eight witnesses to the execution saw Harris mouth the words, Im sorry. Baker nodded his head sharply in acceptance of the apology. This course, says the introduction, can therefore be summed up very simply in this way: Nothing real can be threatened. The abrupt command ended a grueling all-night marathon that court employees said was unlike anything in recent memory. "[15], Harris was executed on April 21, 1992, in the gas chamber at San Quentin State Prison the first execution in California in 25 years. Maybe to God no one is a hopeless case. (To its credit, the state goes to some trouble to determine whether a punishment fits the crime, but the freelance agents of personal justice generally dont worry about such niceties.) He wanted their car for the getaway from the bank robbery. What are the reasonable consequences of a crime for criminals, for victims, for society? What if you were governor and you had to make this real, immediate choice? Acts like rape, robbery, extortion, and murder are odious and repulsive, quite apart from the background of the criminal; they destroy the social consensus that makes civilization possible, and we are completely justified in restoring it at the criminals expense. To get past that, you have to confront your fear., Without a death penalty, I asked Magris, wont many people conclude that murderers can get away with it? Marilyn Clark, the sister of Harriss other victim, attended the execution to honor her deceased mother, who had wanted to be there but died of cancer the year before. Kolender, who was chief of police when Harris killed the two boys, said he hopes the justice system learns from the lengthy legal proceedings -- both from the last-minute appeals and the tedious litigation that blocked the execution for years. But Harris was a force of our nature, human nature, which can perhaps be changed by looking deeply at how our beliefs create our behavior. The older Harris brother, Randall, confirmed Daniels latest account of the facts in a sworn affidavit, noting that Daniel had confessed a few years after leaving prison that his rifle went off first and that Robert then just went crazy and opened fire. A flurry of legal appeals kept delaying what became the states first execution in 25 years. Today Magris is married and lives not far from San Quentin. They forced the boys to drive them to an isolated area, where Robert shot them. Thus, forgiveness is an inherently paradoxical spiritual path. Particularly in America, we seem bent on encouraging the endless cycle of violence feeding upon itself. Crittendon said San Quentin Warden Daniel Vasquez visited Harris for about five minutes about 7:45 p.m. Crittendon said he didnt know what the two discussed. Later, the father would load his gun and tell Robbie to run. When I feel angry and vengeful, I attempt to face those feelings squarely and completely, and then I decide whether I want them to drive my behavior. WebRobert Alton Harris is perhaps the most famous bad-history wrongdoer in the philosophical * I thank Saba Bazargan-Forward, Amy Berg, Matthew Braich, and his brother planned a bank robbery. He then proceeded to persecute them before burying a bullet in both their brains. By denying criminals justice, we live with a growing underclass of violent, hopeless people. Harris, 39, who already had been strapped into the gas-chamber chair once and then removed exactly two hours earlier, was led to the chamber a second time at 6:01 a.m., after the U.S. Supreme Court lifted a one-day stay granted by 9th Circuit Court of Appeals Judge Harry Pregerson. Kevin Leary, a San Francisco Chronicle reporter who witnessed Harris execution and said he has also witnessed a lethal-injection execution, said he prefers that method. In the life history of Robert Alton Harris, two facts stand out: The murders that put him on Death Row were heartless, and he seemed destined to die strapped down in an execution chamber somewhere. One makes choices. By now Robert was ten, and he was questioned by police investigating the killing of cats. Harris was sentenced to die 13 years ago for killing 16-year-olds John Mayeski and Michael Baker in 1978. Native American societies handled murderers this way. But citing the 1st Amendment right of freedom of religion, the judge concluded that Harris would be more willing to clear his conscience to a confidant rather than a stranger offered by the prison. He started slapping Wheeler around about 9 a.m. In addition to mercy and compassion, there is justice and responsibility in this world. Counselors reported that he slashed his wrists in suicide attempts. This process usually feels like ego death, which is precisely what our so-called correctional system should be about suppressing criminal behavior and changing ways of thinking until criminals, whose egos are often saturated with the belief in vengeance, are liberated from that belief. They forced Michael Baker and John Mayeski to drive into a nearby canyon. After some joking and laughter, and a promise no harm would come to them, he told them to start walking. The brothers then drove back to town in the boys' car and robbed a bank. Pete Wilsons televised rejection Thursday of a clemency petition by Harris. We punish murderers because they are the only beings on whom we can act out our anger about death itself, while still regarding ourselves as civilized. Other members of the victims families clutched one another, Hearn said, as they watched Harris die. In 1978, at age 25, Harris was released again, despite warnings from the Imperial County Sheriffs Department to parole authorities that Harris was in need of psychiatric attention.. Gen. Louis Hanoian said no evidence was withheld and the claim that Daniel Harris was hypnotized was an outrageous lie.. In a vengeful and violent society, theres a great temptation simply to eliminate the worst byproducts of our cultural mind-set. A hearing was scheduled in that case before U.S. District Judge Marilyn Hall Patel at 6 p.m. today. If we presume that this surrender is impossible, we ensure that killers like Harris will always be with us as the most extreme perpetrators of our collective belief in vengeance. Robert Alton Harris - IMDb They admitted that managing a house full of teenagers has been a challenge but describe it as a happy experience. Federal Circuits, 9th Cir. It isnt always so clear. But at night I was doing burglaries, drinking, taking and selling drugs.. Civil complaint seeks a court order to require owner Caydon Property Group to remedy all municipal code violations or allow the city to do so at the owners expense. Havent we all been seized at least once by a murderous rage and wondered later what kept us from acting on it? In an age of media conglomerates, were something of an oddity: an ad-free, independent, reader-supported magazine. A similar challenge to the constitutionality of the use of gas, raised in a case from Mississippi, was turned down by a federal appeals court in 1983. Im also for abortion rights, while acknowledging that abortion is murder. It was a serious act. Knowledge of their whereabouts would not materially change his situation, since they appear to be the cause of his delinquency and would offer nothing in the way of stable planning, the report said. You might as well invite mass murderers in for lunch and serve yourself on the menu.
Categories
